Was Barbara Fisher Home, a design studio + home decor shop. The shop is further north than the pedestrian traffic. And set back from the sidewalk. The place is being advertised as retail/office. It is probably a better location for an office. $3,000/month, plus proportional share of utilities. Was $3,700. Two year lease.

Listing by Katie Schimpf, Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty. 908-246-4855. Also Bill McIntosh 516-857-4645.
Full details at LoopNet

Owner: 449 MAIN HOLDINGS LLC, PO BOX 942, MATTITUCK, NY 11952

Was Shearer Shop Antiques. Before that Bob Tasker's law office. Space is now empty. Sale price is $979,000.

Being set back from the street, it will be hard to get window shoppers. There could be wheelchair access issues.

Sign in front has Remax City Square 516-731-2700 x113. Also Laurel O'Mara, Team Barry Homes 516-209-9627. laurel@teambarryhomes.com
Corcoran [has many inside pictures]

Was The ARC Room, a high-end women's wear, accessories, and jewelry store.

No broker listing found. Phone number in window is 631-506-4701 (Maegan Welch). Called and left message twice. Did not get a call back.

Owner: LAMBROU BUILDING LLC, 122 SOUTH ST, GREENPORT, NY 11944

Former Desiderio's Restaurant & Pizzeria. Plans were filed for a restaurant with apartments upstairs. But the plans have been stymied by the parking laws, business approval processes, and moratoriums. Many documents can be found on the Village agenda pages for the Planning Commission.

Not for sale or rent.

Owner: MAIN & CENTRAL RTY LLC, 2760 YENNECOTT DR, SOUTHOLD, NY 11971

Was Sweet Indulgences. And before that, the laundromat. There was an attempt to tear this down and build a 18-room hotel. It did not get through planning. No parking. Planning wanted 21 stalls. See Plans.
Sale for $1,950,000 or $5,000/month lease. Short-term lease okay. Previously they were asking $15k a month triple net, but would "entertain" $10k.
Marketing was suggesting an art gallery.

Sign in window has For Sale Sheri Winter Parker 631-848-7730 Corcoran
Zillow [off-market according to them, but has inside pictures]

Owner: HF2HOTEL OWNER LLC, 372 COURT ST FL 2, BROOKLYN, NY 11231

Was Kharmah, Linda Gerien's boutique. In Wm. Mills old building.
$3,200 per month. Electric heat. Central air.

Article on Kharmah closing in The Suffolk Times

Sign in window has Sheri Winter Parker 631-848-7730 Corcoran
LoopNet
Christie's

Owner: PWIB CLAUDIO REAL EST LLC, 111 MAIN ST, GREENPORT, NY 11944

Turn-key professional space perfect for an office, small shop, or home business looking to grow. $1,900/month lease

Signature Premier Properties, Paul J. White Listing Contact: 631-751-2111
Howard Hanna
Coldwell Banker

For sale or lease. Owner, David Akcay, is adamant that the space is "turn-key."

Article in The Suffolk Times
Article from when the Arcade shut down in 2017: The Suffolk Times

Sign in window has Michael Murphy 631-858-2460 ellimancommercial.com and Kristy Naddell 631-905-8584
Elliman Commercial
Showcase.com
LoopNet

Owner: 2012 FRONT STREET LLC, 122 SOUTH ST, GREENPORT, NY 11944

Was Salumeria Sarto cheese shop. Opened spring 2023, closed fall 2024. Before that it was Kate's Cheese.

$5,000/month lease. Reduced price. Was $6,500/month. Offered as a triple net lease (tenant pays base rent plus three additional property expenses: property taxes, building insurance, and maintenance) with potential rent concession from landlord based on use and term.

Listing broker: Shannon O'Shea with East End Luxury Ltd - 843-303-0995. Sign in window has eastendluxury.com [non-functioning website] 631-477-6626.
Prior Corcoran and Genstone Realty web pages gone. No current broker listing found on web. Email sent to Shannon. No response.

Owner: KATHLEEN M WOLFF, 51540 ROUTE 25, SOUTHOLD, NY 11971

$6,000/month lease. Was The Market for 18 years at this location. Article on the closing in northforker.

Sign in window: Thomas J. McCarthy Real Estate 631-765-5815 main office, and 516-779-6386 direct. Email: tmccarthy.tmccarthy@gmail.com
Coldwell Banker, Village Green Realty

Owner: 38-44 FRONT STREET LLC, 1044 PARKWAY ST, RIVERHEAD, NY 11901

Now is Greenhill Kitchen. Restaurant is still open.

Sale price is $2,850,000. Was $2,900,000. The sale is of the building. The restaurant will vacate, but the restaurant can be bought in a separate transaction.

Douglas Elliman

Owner: 48 FRONT ST PROP LLC, PO BOX 558, SAGAPONACK, NY 11962

Was Tikal Latin Cuisine (two spaces). Was Casa Amigos, and before that Agave Grill & Cantina. Other two spaces vacant for a long time (Vines & Branches and The Cotton Caper).
Asking price of $30 / Price Per SQFT. Five separate spaces of varying size. Can be combined.
Four of five spaces: 3,000 SF, 2,500 SF, 2,500 SF and 1,500 SF. Can be combined to get 9,000 SF.
This is a monthly rent of $7,500, $6,250, $6,250 and $3,750. Combined $22,500.
All five spaces together total 16,300 sq ft. That is a total rent of $40,750 per month.
POP-UP Availability and month to month only. Property is in probate.

Sign in window has Signature Premier Properties, Lisa Lauricella lisa.lauicella13@gmail.com 516-297-1188 and Janine Gleusner jgleusner@signaturepremuier.com 516-637-4842
LoopNet [has details on four]
Coach Realtors
Coldwell Banker

Owner: GUSMAR ENTERPRISES LLC, C/O ERNEST EDWARD BADWAY ESQ, 100 PARK AVE STE 1500, NEW YORK, NY 10017

Was Not Just Bows. They moved to Main St next to Lucharitos.

No broker listing. Sign in window has 631-495-1724. Called. Rent is $2,500.

Owner: EU LLC, C/O ALI ERGIS, 26 FRONT ST, GREENPORT, NY 11944

Sale price is $895,000. No rent option.

This was VSOP Art + Design Projects, a contemporay art gallery. It has closed and is moving to the Hudson Valley, per Northforker. This is two-story gallery, with no residential component. Previously was Werkshop.

See what the building looked like in 2013. The first floor windows were changed by VSOP in 2017, when they moved in.

Corcoran

Owner: WEISKOPF REAL EST HLDNG LLC, 400 LONG CREEK DR, SOUTHOLD, NY 11971